Analysis

Whey won The Economist's protein test. What dairy should do next

The Economist has ruled whey the best protein powder for anyone who trains. For people who make and sell dairy, the verdict matters less than what follows from it. Labels cannot show dairy's advantage, and the value whey now earns often does not reach the business that made it.

Independent analysis by The Dairy Mail. Not sponsored; the interpretation is our own. Our editorial standards.

A scoop of chocolate whey protein powder resting in a bed of loose powder

Last month The Economist asked whether some protein powders are better than others (23 October 2026). Its answer, for anyone recovering from exercise, was a full dose of plain whey. Whey carries more leucine, the amino acid that tells muscle to rebuild, than casein, pea or soya. We agree with the science. Our view is that the article answers a shopper's question. People who make and sell dairy need to know what that advantage is worth to their business, and who gets paid for it.

Start with the shelf. Under retained Regulation 1924/2006, a food may claim to be a "source of protein" when protein supplies 12% of its energy, and "high protein" at 20% (legislation.gov.uk). The test counts quantity, not quality. A pea drink and a whey drink with the same grams of protein carry the same claim. Yet on DIAAS, the score that rates a protein by the amino acids the body actually absorbs, whey protein isolate rates 1.09 and pea protein concentrate 0.82. The full table is at the foot of this piece.

The Economist warns shoppers about powders padded with low-quality amino acids or bulked up with starches, gums and emulsifiers. Amino-acid padding works because protein is often measured from nitrogen, and free amino acids add nitrogen without adding much muscle-building value. We are not aware of a UK rule that stops it. The nearest is a voluntary 2014 US trade policy that counts as protein only amino acids joined by peptide bonds (AHPA).

Premium analysis

Keep reading as a free member

Free membership: up to four premium articles or reports a month, and a weekly digest of the most important developments.

Want every premium article and report? Become a paid member.

Premium analysis

You have read your four free pieces this month

Members read every premium article and report, with no monthly limit. Your free reads start again on the first of next month.

We could not open this article just now

Please try again in a moment. If it keeps happening, let us know.

Published by The Dairy Mail, Dairy Connect: https://www.dairy-connect.com/the-dairy-mail/whey-won-the-protein-test/

GROW by Dairy Connect

Is the plant leaving value on the table?

GROW's production optimisation work looks at yield, consistency, productivity and capacity from intake to dispatch, with named dairy specialists rather than generalists.

Upcoming

Where this conversation happens next.

Cork · 3 & 4 March 2027

Dairy Forum Ireland

Relevant to

Technical & Processing, Leadership & Strategy, Commercial & Sales, Artisan & SME

Why attend

How do we create more value from dairy? Fourteen speakers across five sessions follow milk from the farm to the market, closing on a summary panel. Opens with an evening of cheese and whiskey.

Stafford · 23 & 24 June 2027

International Cheese & Dairy EXPO

Relevant to

Retail & Foodservice, Artisan & SME, Suppliers & Technology, Technical & Processing

Why attend

Two days for the whole cheese and dairy supply chain, held with the International Cheese & Dairy Awards: a retail focus and ICDA judging on day one, a foodservice focus and the awards presentation on day two.